By Phil Huber, ADVANCE COLUMNIST
Republicans were right to investigate Hunter Biden. When the family of a powerful public official receives foreign money, holds lucrative overseas business positions, or appears to market access to government, Congress has a duty to ask questions. It should seek documents, hear sworn testimony, trace financial flows and determine whether public power was used for private gain.
That principle should not be partisan. It should not disappear because the president is a Republican—or because the family name is Trump. The proper question is not whether Congress should declare anyone guilty. It is whether Congress should apply the same threshold for oversight to every president and every presidential family.
Democrats did not uniformly oppose scrutiny of Hunter Biden. In 2023, Rep. Dan Goldman, a New York Democrat, said that if Hunter Biden had committed illegal acts, “he should face charges.” Other Democrats argued that the Justice Department’s investigation should proceed while rejecting the claim that the House inquiry had proved wrongdoing by President Joe Biden.
That is an important distinction. A legitimate investigation of Hunter Biden did not automatically establish guilt by Joe Biden. Likewise, legitimate scrutiny of Trump-family business dealings would not establish that Donald Trump committed a crime. Investigations exist to sort evidence from insinuation.
Sen. John Curtis, a Utah Republican, recently offered the most sensible model. He asked the Senate Judiciary Committee to investigate the business dealings and foreign relationships of both Donald Trump Jr. and Hunter Biden, and to subpoena them for testimony. Curtis argued that the country should not accept one standard for a Republican president’s family and another for a Democratic president’s family.
That should be Congress’s rule. The House pursued the Biden-family matter because it saw warning signs: foreign money, valuable family connections, business activity and possible access to a senior official. It did not wait for a final bribery conviction before opening hearings, seeking bank records or demanding testimony. If those facts justified inquiry, then, comparable facts should justify inquiry now.
Consider the president’s $TRUMP memecoin. Its promoters offered the top holders an invitation to dine privately with the president at his Northern Virginia golf club, with additional VIP access for the highest-ranking buyers. Thirty-six House Democrats asked the Justice Department to investigate whether the promotion raised bribery and foreign-emoluments concerns, citing the possibility of anonymous and foreign purchasers buying access to the president.
That request did not prove a crime, and neither should anyone claim that it did. The question for Congress is simpler: Who bought the token? Did foreign governments, state-linked enterprises, lobbyists, regulated companies or people seeking pardons or policy changes participate? What access did they receive? What records exist? Those are ordinary oversight questions.
The reported UAE investment in World Liberty Financial raises a similar issue. Congressional materials describe a reported $500 million purchase of a 49 percent stake in the Trump-family-affiliated crypto company by entities linked to Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the UAE national-security adviser. The UAE later obtained more favorable treatment for applications involving advanced U.S. computing equipment.
Timing alone does not establish a quid pro quo. CNBC reported that there was no evidence the UAE-linked investment influenced the Commerce Department’s decision, while administration officials cited national-security safeguards and the UAE’s defense relationship with the United States. Those are relevant defenses, and they should be evaluated fairly.
But an innocent explanation is not a reason to forbid questions. It is a reason to ask them carefully. Congress should examine the policy record, communications among agencies, contacts with Trump-family businesses, investor identities, ethics reviews and safeguards against conflicts. It should hear from career officials as well as political appointees. Then it should publish its findings.
A serious inquiry should also avoid a double standard in the other direction. Congress should not assume that a family member’s foreign business connection automatically implicates the president. House Democrats made that point about Joe Biden after reviewing testimony from the Republican-led inquiry. The same caution applies to Donald Trump. Evidence—not party loyalty, headlines or suspicion alone—must decide whether wrongdoing occurred.
Still, caution is not silence. If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it may not be a duck. But it is enough to take a closer look. Congress has already established the principle that foreign money, family business and proximity to presidential power warrant rigorous inquiry. It should now apply that principle without fear or favor.
With elections approaching, voters should ask every House and Senate candidate: Do you believe Congress should investigate credible evidence of foreign money, family business and presidential access no matter whose name is on the door? If your answer was yes for Hunter Biden but no for Donald Trump Jr., explain the difference.
The remedy is not a partisan fishing expedition. It is a bipartisan review with clear questions, defined records, sworn testimony and public findings. Follow the money. Identify the buyers. Examine the official decisions. Protect due process. And apply one standard—to Biden, to Trump and to every future president.
***
Phil Huber is a retired Army Reserve colonel, a federal civil servant, and a retired consultant who writes on civic education. He lives in Fredericksburg.



Dear Colonel,
I can't help but feel reminded of the late Paul Harvey when I read your columns.
Particularly this one.
In that you really.....REALLY left out the rest of the story.
Yes, Congress should apply a uniform standard when investigating corruption.
And should they, I suspect, based upon the scale of the questions, the known (and often proven in a court of law despite untold wealth and privilege) lack of decent character of those suspected, and the unprecedented subservience of Republicans to their party over our society, they will find they have not done a hundredth of what they should.
But that is most certainly not the remedy, in and of itself.
By no means.
To believe that doesn't rank much lower than the credulity necessary to believe in the Tooth Fairy or Santa Claus.
The rot in our system is much, much deeper.
And I would posit that creating that doubt and rot has been the aim of "conservatives" for well over 50 years, and likely longer. You can find traces in the age of the 1st robber barons, during and after Roosevelt's New Deal, and after the Civil Rights acts of the '60s.
But it has come to full fruition in the last decade. Particularly in the last two years.
A descent into madness which rivals that of the most despotic tyrants of old.
They are winning the state's rights debate that seemed settled after our 1st Civil War. Our national protections, which seemed so strong 30 years ago are now a shadow of themselves.
Standards ignored, studies suppressed, monies withheld. Teachers and knowledge attacked by the state which should be supporting them.
Of course those with power would rather see 50 disunited states with limited resources, or 1000's of communities with even less trying to protect our citizens rather than one uniform United States government, or even worse - an organization of United Nations with uniform global laws and rights.
Why wouldn't they?
It seems the only true checks we have on their power is if another billionaire opposes them.
And even then, they can be coopted. That seems to be where the only true debate and compromise occurs (see Bezos, Musk, Gates, et. al.).
Between attorneys, compromised civil servants, controlled media (did you seen the Warner-Paramount merger just went thru?), influencers, etc. - what hope do we have against this modern rendition of Hobbe's Leviathan?
In this new age of an old tale, we've learned that during the Nadir of Nixon, folks like William Barr supported an obscure Justice Department white paper that made the basic claim that while a President is in office, he is above the law.
An opinion which was never legally enacted into law, after deliberation and consent of Congress, or rulings by the courts of the time. Just quietly filed away until a President they liked did something that would otherwise be illegal.
I'm sure their reasoning was well meant. But I doubt even they could envision a scenario where the other two branches of the government would be so corrupted as well.
Because now, we find our judicial protections as flimsy as a paper tiger.
Long established rights that were promised by these same justices to be established laws such as Roe v Wade now have been casually dropped once those same justices had the votes to do so.
Both citizens and non-citizens subject to racial profiling - cruel and unusual punishments, and death from agents of the state who are operating with both anonymity and impunity. With billions appropriated to increase their power. Arbitrary death on the high seas and assassinations of foreign leaders on the flimsiests of pretexts.
With the only thing that seems to be currently holding those in power in check is the upcoming election.
Which, btw, they have shown every intention of attacking - with their open suppression of international monitors, promises of voter intimidation, past history of attempting to overthrow the democratic process.
As many other dictators have done in the past. It's happened before, just not here. Will they have the guts to follow thru?
They did 6 years ago, and this time they're more organized. So now we wait and see.
That time, it happened when they had much more ethical people in place.
Or do you see Hegseth as more ethical than Mattis? Patel compared to Wray? Vance to Pence? Blanche than Barr?
BTW, those were rhetorical....
Shadow dockets rule the day, and even when the executive branch is chastised - it is years after the harm has been done, and even more egregious harms have replaced it. By the very people who should realize the most that justice delayed is justice denied.
What good does it do to outlaw an arbitrary tax (tariff) based upon one wrong application of the law, when there is nothing stopping the executive from merely replacing it with another also based upon bad faith and arbitrary whims?
Faithful civil servants, many of whom are, or once were our neighbors, and all who are our fellow citizens; who have longed reasonably believed they were protected from partisanship by law are now casually fired, find their speech suppressed, and themselves personally subject to mob attacks both physical and virtual for doing their sworn duty.
On and on.
Military, mutual defense treaties, power to declare war, environmental protections, business protections, all the pillars of our civil society systemically destroyed or suppressed.
You say that once Congress makes a public finding the job is done. But that's not true is it?
For the President or his cabinet, you would need a majority in the House, but would require a 2/3rds majority in the Senate - in which Republicans have already shown twice they will ignore both law and facts for their party. And those not doing so will be drummed out of the party.
And our Congress is even more worthless on everyday issues.
Schumer or Johnson, they all eat at the same trough. More interested in staying in the game than actually performing their duties. More loyal to party than principle. And amazingly, never quite able to reach a 2/3rds majority on the stuff that matters.
And Kavanaugh gets JUST enough votes to get confirmed, tee-hee. With only the Republicans most at risk from voters voting no. As long as it doesn't matter. Performative art, not true votes of principle.
No matter how much people want it otherwise. The vast majority support reasonable gun controls like safe storage requirements, nationalized healthcare for all, a workable immigrations system, fair honest taxation, etc.
Yet we don't get them.
And last, but certainly not least - let's not forget ourselves. The voters. The citizens.
You are an admitted world traveler, man of knowledge and influence. A leader, dedicated public citizen. Yet, by your own admission, you are not "political".
It took you until the last two years before you could come to the conclusion this wasn't right?
And even now, your concerns, the best arguments for change you can make are that we'll be better off at the grocery store, the gas station?!?!?
Our honor doesn't matter, our oaths, Constitution, rule of law, common human decency, air we breathe, children's future, advancement of knowledge, kindness - none of those are reason enough to stand against this madness?
If that's the best hope we can get from someone of your high calibre, respectfully Sir, I fear we really are destined to live our own version of Pastor Niemoller's prophetic poem.
There must be something more to our lives than our next tank of gas for us to plan our lives around. And we must be realistic of the hard work that awaits us to make that happen.
I wish it were as easy and simple as you say. It isn't.
Good day.