FROM THE EDITOR: Trumpian Fear of the Other Comes to the Fredericksburg Region
Trump said he's fighting for "hardworking" Americans. He's forgotten that includes immigrants. We shouldn't make the same mistake.
By Martin Davis
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Email Martin
Local politics matter because most of the time they have more impact on people’s day-to-day lives than politics at the state or national level. Further, citizens can have considerably more impact on their local politics than at the higher levels.
There are, however, exceptions to every rule.
On Wednesday evening Donald Trump delivered a factually- and grammatically-challenged address to the nation rife with animosity for the other. He blamed immigrants for the surging costs of rental properties, stealing jobs, and stressing hospital emergency rooms while living high on the taxpayer’s dime getting free health care and education.
These prevarications and canards are so routine that it’s easy to become inured to the untruths behind them and the damage these words do.
Until it hits home.
Yesterday, the Advance was first to report ICE’s detention of Mirna Benitez.
Told to report to the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement office in North Chesterfield on Sunday, December 7, Benitez did what she has dutifully done since coming to the United States — following the rules and reporting when asked to do so by government officials.
She has worked for a decade for a contracted company at the same local school. She pays her taxes. She owns a home and cars. And she has been working toward citizenship. And save for paying a $30 fine in 2016 for failing to obey a highway sign, Benitez had no run-ins with law enforcement.
She is no anomaly. According to the CATO Institute — a libertarian think-tank in Washington, D.C. — Immigrants:
are less likely to be incarcerated in prisons, convicted of crimes, or arrested than native-born Americans.
don’t take American jobs, lower wages, or push the poor out of the labor market.
use significantly less welfare than native-born Americans.
have about a net zero effect on government budgets — they pay about as much in taxes as they consume in benefits.
While hard numbers are difficult to come by, the Migration Policy Institute estimates that there are roughly 360,000 undocumented people in Virginia. They work jobs like Benitez’s.
They also work in construction, retail trade, and professional jobs.
They are, in fact, the backbones of our local communities.
The worry now is that Benitez represents the first of a surge of ICE arrests and deportations. On Thursday, fear swept through Spotsylvania as there were worries that ICE was active at the Spotsylvania Mall.
As of this writing, it’s not clear precisely what was happening.
Major Delbert Myrick of the Spotsylvania County Sheriff’s Office told the Advance by phone that there was a task force operation carried out by the Virginia State Police and the FBI Thursday morning, but that activity was totally unrelated to any immigration activity.
There are also concerns that there were ICE arrests made at the entrance to the Bragg Hill Community on Tuesday. The Advance has not confirmed this with federal agencies or with Fredericksburg City Police as of this writing.
Regardless what happened at the mall and at Bragg Hill, there is no denying the terror this news has caused the immigrant community in our region.
Even before these events, many of our immigrant neighbors have been living in fear. That was the finding of Eric Bonds, who along with Aaliyah Anderson and Tabitha Van Doren, interviewed five people from three families of mixed immigration statuses, meaning that some members of these families have citizenship, while others do not.
Bonds wrote:
As U.S. citizens, we’ve paid attention to aspects of the Trump Administration’s immigration policy as it’s been reported in the national news, typically in coverage of dramatic immigration raids in major cities like DC, Los Angeles, and Chicago. This, we realized, left us with a false sense of comfort, the feeling that “at least it’s not happening here.”
After having conversations with undocumented persons in our own community, we realize how wrong that attitude is. Families are suffering in the Fredericksburg region because of federal policies on mass deportation.
Those fears were greatly amplified on Thursday as social media pages lit up with the police activity, and posters writing in English and Spanish were warning people to steer clear of the activity for fear that they could be taken and deported.
Benitez’s experience explains why people have reason to fear. Elizabeth Jones, a family friend, told the Advance that “[Benitez] was put on a plane—she said the plane was unsanitary and pretty terrifying, so much so that the pilot, as soon as they landed in Texas, he ran off the plane. … Mirna told her daughter and best friend that her things were covered in urine. She’s since been transferred to Louisiana, which is also not great. The facilities are unsanitary and she got an infection.”
For the near future, we are stuck with a president determined to continue stoking fear, spreading prevarications and canards about immigrants, and treating hardworking people like Benitez as less than human.
Benitez’s stories and others in her situation should force all of us to sit back and take stock of the kind of community we want to live in.
The ugliest repercussions of Trump’s obsession with hatred for the other is landing with full force in our region, but we don’t have to succumb to the inhumanity that drives it. For now, we can show more compassion for those who live in fear of having family members snatched from them — or finding themselves on an unsanitary plane to Texas.
We can support organizations that are standing and fighting for immigrants’ rights and helping those who are working toward citizenship to realize that goal.
Most important, we can vote at every level for politicians who reject the debasement of people simply because of where they came from.
The American immigration system has been broken for at least 40 years. That’s not the fault of the immigrants, and it certainly isn’t right to punish them for our collective failure.
It’s past time to demand that politicians fix the system they have allowed to break and find a way to treat those who are here without proper documentation with respect and humanity.
On Wednesday night, Trump declared:
you have a president who fights for the law-abiding, hardworking people of our country. The ones who make this nation run, who make this nation work.
Those law-abiding, hardworking people, the ones who make this nation work include the immigrants who have come here to find a better future for their families.
Trump has forgotten that.
Patriots and defenders of the best that America represents have not, and must not.
Local Obituaries
To view local obituaries or to send a note to family and loved ones, please visit the link that follows.
Support Award-winning, Locally Focused Journalism
The FXBG Advance cuts through the talking points to deliver both incisive and informative news about the issues, people, and organizations that daily affect your life. And we do it in a multi-partisan format that has no equal in this region. Over the past year, our reporting was:
First to break the story of Stafford Board of Supervisors dismissing a citizen library board member for “misconduct,” without informing the citizen or explaining what the person allegedly did wrong.
First to explain falling water levels in the Rappahannock Canal.
First to detail controversial traffic numbers submitted by Stafford staff on the Buc-ee’s project
Our media group also offers the most-extensive election coverage in the region and regular columnists like:
And our newsroom is led by the most-experienced and most-awarded journalists in the region — Adele Uphaus (Managing Editor and multiple VPA award-winner) and Martin Davis (Editor-in-Chief, 2022 Opinion Writer of the Year in Virginia and more than 25 years reporting from around the country and the world).
For just $8 a month, you can help support top-flight journalism that puts people over policies.
Your contributions 100% support our journalists.
Help us as we continue to grow!
This article is published under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND. It can be distributed for noncommercial purposes and must include the following: “Published with permission by FXBG Advance.”
Public debate on immigration is saturated with morality tales about desperate families, “open borders,” and “invasions,” but it rarely explains how today’s elected and appointed officials are structuring this crisis. Much of the media frames immigration as a clash of values—cruelty versus compassion, law and order versus humanitarian concern—without spelling out how Congress, the current administration, and the courts are jointly responsible for the chaos.
Congress, under both parties, has failed for decades to pass basic updates to immigration law, even though everyone knows the system’s quotas, categories, and procedures no longer match economic needs or global displacement realities. Instead of doing the hard work of legislating, today’s Congress often uses immigration as a campaign weapon, highlighting tragedies at the border while blocking workable compromises. That inaction forces presidents to govern by executive orders and agency rules, pushing the current administration, like its predecessors, to stretch enforcement and humanitarian tools right up to legal limits.
The courts then step in, not as moral referees, but as emergency managers—deciding, case by case, which executive actions stand and which fall. This produces abrupt policy swings and leaves the public with headlines about “wins” and “losses,” rather than a clear sense of what a just, durable framework would look like.
I recommend future immigration articles explain the failures in Congress, the White House, and the judiciary, otherwise citizens are denied the full picture—and the system remains broken by design. Migrants will continue to be denied just, humane, and dignified treatment, and due process. We need this information to hold our elected officials to their responsibilities.