To Common Man: This is not a personal fight between 2 individuals. I am the third cofounder of the Advance, Leigh Anne Van Doren. Without me, the Advance would not exist. To clarify: Martin and Shaun were the co founders of a substack called F2S after Martin was laid off from the FLS. I identified Martin’s excellent reporting on our schools and I offered him an already established platform through my 3 year old nonprofit. Since 2020, I had been planning a nonprofit newsroom as one of my programs and I was looking for a good editorial team. My goals were and are bigger than giving employment to any one particular person. These goals include a commitment to covering how power works in our community, who gets talked about and who doesn’t, who gets a level playing field and who doesn’t, all on a platform built for the long term so that consistent attention can be paid to under-covered issues in the community. I have known Shaun for 30 years and still enjoy working with him. Martins goals no longer aligned with the Advance, so I was happy to wish him well and replace him with the fine editor we have now.
It would be fantastic to also explore who with in the city both elected, appointed and on city payrolls are also deeply in bed with data center money. Currently, former elected, appointed and city staff! Thorough is always best. If you’re going to expose the entire cast of characters not just some you want to hit, that’s good journalism!
Thanks Steve there are many many more parts to this story and the community deserves to know what’s been kept from them by everyone and how deep the back door deals are and how well so many have been bought. It’s people we both know well and it won’t be pretty if it can truly be completely exposed as it should be! it seems no one is willing to call the entire cast of characters out. Other news publications too are involved and that makes it the worst.
Any suggestions, names, connections we might look into, I hope you'll send them along through private email, or phone call, Mary. Thanks for your comments here.
Can't speak for anyone beyond myself, but as noted above, I found it informative. I didn't know that publications have a requirement not to say anything negative about other sources that purport to be unbiased, when there are credible reasons, such as their funding, lack of disclosure, etc. that give legitimate reasons to question that claim.
In fact, I would consider it a duty of those other publications to provide that information.
And certainly consider that information that this publication has legitimate value.
I have no problem with calling out hypocrisy where it lies but the article didn’t mention that Shaun and Marty are the exact same people that founded the Advance and have been friends for many years. It also didn’t mention that the Advance has almost an entirely partisan 1-sided Board and Staff. It also didn’t show any sort of misrepresentation from the other publication or any wrongdoing.
The article was just a poor written attempt a bitter jealously in my opinion. Even the last line was written as an attack on someone merely because he wouldn’t make a comment.
I read that last sentence and took it as an honest representation of the facts. If it was wrong, I, and I'd expect - the writer would welcome hearing it.
Again, I find it refreshing to find someone not making a questionable pretense of having no personal opinion or values, at the same time they are spinning things to represent a predetermined viewpoint.
Coincidentally?!? after creating a venue name that closely resembles a local news source that has developed as a credible news source that does seem to clearly differentiate between their puff pieces, and hard reporting.
To someone " in the know" the facts he presents may be old hat or have a perfectly innocent reason.
Though they seem to at least raise the appearance of being a publication who purports to be non=partisan, yet has known close personal and financial associations with people and/or organizations with agendas and significant wealth to throw around on issues that may conflict with the general publics best interests, and have other associations which they have chosen to hide, which in this day and age, would give any impartial trier of facts at least a reasonable suspicion that there is something even more unseemly or conflicting which is why they've chosen not to share it. .
Also sounds like Mr Watkins gave those he was discussing an opportunity to provide their viewpoint or an opportunity to respond prior to publication and they chose not to give it.
Not sure how that's his fault.
Anyway....I have a better understanding of these issues now, and for that, I'm grateful.
To Common Man: This is not a personal fight between 2 individuals. I am the third cofounder of the Advance, Leigh Anne Van Doren. Without me, the Advance would not exist. To clarify: Martin and Shaun were the co founders of a substack called F2S after Martin was laid off from the FLS. I identified Martin’s excellent reporting on our schools and I offered him an already established platform through my 3 year old nonprofit. Since 2020, I had been planning a nonprofit newsroom as one of my programs and I was looking for a good editorial team. My goals were and are bigger than giving employment to any one particular person. These goals include a commitment to covering how power works in our community, who gets talked about and who doesn’t, who gets a level playing field and who doesn’t, all on a platform built for the long term so that consistent attention can be paid to under-covered issues in the community. I have known Shaun for 30 years and still enjoy working with him. Martins goals no longer aligned with the Advance, so I was happy to wish him well and replace him with the fine editor we have now.
It would be fantastic to also explore who with in the city both elected, appointed and on city payrolls are also deeply in bed with data center money. Currently, former elected, appointed and city staff! Thorough is always best. If you’re going to expose the entire cast of characters not just some you want to hit, that’s good journalism!
Any suggestions for following up on are always welcome, Mary.
Thanks Steve there are many many more parts to this story and the community deserves to know what’s been kept from them by everyone and how deep the back door deals are and how well so many have been bought. It’s people we both know well and it won’t be pretty if it can truly be completely exposed as it should be! it seems no one is willing to call the entire cast of characters out. Other news publications too are involved and that makes it the worst.
Any suggestions, names, connections we might look into, I hope you'll send them along through private email, or phone call, Mary. Thanks for your comments here.
Perhaps a FOIA request to local jurisdictions for copies of any NDAs signed by elected/appointed officials, and any jurisdictional staff.
Well this was informative. Thank you.
Sad, but informative. Look forward to hearing any response, but this certainly explains a lot.
I continue to wish Ms Uphaus well. Her work has been a bright light on the local scene.
As for the others, I think for once, I'll follow my Mother's advice for when I didn't have anything nice to say.....
VFP needs to come clean about the source of their funding.
What’s the point of this article besides for one publication to attack another. What a waste of breath
Can't speak for anyone beyond myself, but as noted above, I found it informative. I didn't know that publications have a requirement not to say anything negative about other sources that purport to be unbiased, when there are credible reasons, such as their funding, lack of disclosure, etc. that give legitimate reasons to question that claim.
In fact, I would consider it a duty of those other publications to provide that information.
And certainly consider that information that this publication has legitimate value.
Freshest breath I've noted in a while.
I have no problem with calling out hypocrisy where it lies but the article didn’t mention that Shaun and Marty are the exact same people that founded the Advance and have been friends for many years. It also didn’t mention that the Advance has almost an entirely partisan 1-sided Board and Staff. It also didn’t show any sort of misrepresentation from the other publication or any wrongdoing.
The article was just a poor written attempt a bitter jealously in my opinion. Even the last line was written as an attack on someone merely because he wouldn’t make a comment.
Hmm.
Potaytoe-potahtoe
I read that last sentence and took it as an honest representation of the facts. If it was wrong, I, and I'd expect - the writer would welcome hearing it.
Again, I find it refreshing to find someone not making a questionable pretense of having no personal opinion or values, at the same time they are spinning things to represent a predetermined viewpoint.
Coincidentally?!? after creating a venue name that closely resembles a local news source that has developed as a credible news source that does seem to clearly differentiate between their puff pieces, and hard reporting.
To someone " in the know" the facts he presents may be old hat or have a perfectly innocent reason.
Though they seem to at least raise the appearance of being a publication who purports to be non=partisan, yet has known close personal and financial associations with people and/or organizations with agendas and significant wealth to throw around on issues that may conflict with the general publics best interests, and have other associations which they have chosen to hide, which in this day and age, would give any impartial trier of facts at least a reasonable suspicion that there is something even more unseemly or conflicting which is why they've chosen not to share it. .
Also sounds like Mr Watkins gave those he was discussing an opportunity to provide their viewpoint or an opportunity to respond prior to publication and they chose not to give it.
Not sure how that's his fault.
Anyway....I have a better understanding of these issues now, and for that, I'm grateful.
Moving on.